Most people treat soil as the thing underneath the part they care about. It is the other way around. Nearly every lawn problem in this valley that gets diagnosed as a water problem is actually a soil problem wearing a water problem's clothes.
The thing that is counterintuitive about Montana soil
Our soils are not infertile. In many cases they are genuinely rich. The problem is that a significant share of what is in them is held in a form plants cannot take up. The nutrient is physically present and biologically unavailable, which from the plant's point of view is the same as not being there at all.
What unlocks it is biology rather than chemistry. Soil microbes convert bound nutrients into forms a root can actually absorb. Feed the biology and the soil starts delivering what it already contained. Skip the biology and you are left applying more inputs to compensate for a pantry that is full and locked.
Why this shows up as a watering problem
Here is the sentence worth remembering. A starved plant looks like a thirsty plant.
Pale color, slow growth, wilting in afternoon heat, thin turf. Those are the symptoms everyone reads as not enough water, so the response is to water more. More water on a plant with a shallow root system and poor nutrient availability does not fix the cause and does raise the bill. Meanwhile the root system stays shallow, because roots have no reason to go looking for water that is being delivered to the surface every single day.
Deeper roots need less water. That is the whole mechanism. Everything else is detail.
Why fall specifically
Top growth stops well before soil activity does. The visible part of the plant goes dormant while the ground below is still working, and that gap is the window. Amendments and organic matter worked in during October spend the entire winter integrating into the soil profile rather than sitting on top of it.
There is also a practical argument. Soil work in spring competes with everything else on the calendar, and the growing season starts whether the soil is ready or not. Soil work in October has nothing competing with it and a six month head start.
What this looks like in practice
Core aeration to relieve compaction, which in new construction is usually severe and almost never addressed. Organic matter worked into the profile rather than spread across the top. Testing, so you are correcting what is actually wrong rather than what is commonly wrong. And a seeding approach suited to going into cold ground if you are repairing turf.
None of this is dramatic and none of it photographs well. It is also the single highest return work you can do on a property, and the month to do it is this one.
It is the best time. Soil biological activity continues after top growth stops, so amendments worked in during October integrate through the dormant season and are available when growth resumes. Soil corrected in spring spends the first half of the season catching up.
Pale, thin, slow growing turf is frequently a nutrient availability problem rather than a water problem. Montana soils often hold nutrients in forms plants cannot absorb. A starved plant presents much like a thirsty one, which is why the common response of watering more does not resolve it.
Deeper, better-established root systems reach moisture further down the profile and are less dependent on frequent surface watering. Shallow roots caused by daily light watering keep a lawn permanently dependent on irrigation.
Fall aeration relieves compaction ahead of the dormant season and lets amendments and organic matter reach the root zone rather than sitting on the surface. On new construction lots, where soil is usually heavily compacted during building, it matters more than almost anything else you can do.